It has come to the attention of the Law Office of Sheela
Murthy that the four INS Service Centers have begun confirming the validity of educational
and employment records submitted in connection with H-1B petitions. INS can fax the
documents to the U.S. Consulates in India for investigation. The Consulate the responds to
INS requests within 2 to 4 weeks. When the documents are determined to be authentic,
the INS processes the H1B petition promptly.
The Nebraska Service Center has provided the following alarming statistics. The Consulate
has found 32% of the educational documents and 74% of the experience letters for H1B
Petitions from Indian candidates to be fraudulent. The Law Office of Sheela Murthy
questions such statistics. We recently have been involved in addressing a case in which
the H1B candidate had mentioned the name of a prior employer on his resume. The U.S.
Consulate at Chennai (Madras) attempted to verify if the H1B Beneficiary had worked there.
Since the prior employer had moved its location and there was a change of address and
telephone number, the Consulate was not able to contact the employer at the telephone
number provided on its old letterhead, and thus concluded the experience letter to be
fraudulent. In fact, the company still exists but the Consulate has denied the candidate
the H1B visa on the basis that the experience on the resume is fraudulent. The Law Office
of Sheela Murthy has contacted the U.S. State Department Visa Office and is attempting to
resolve this issue with the Chennai consulate.
Such instances are not uncommon and the Law Office of Sheela Murthy has been involved in a
variety of situations with Consulates all over the world when erroneous decisions are
rendered. Certainly, fraudulent documents are a significant problem worldwide for U.S.
Consulates, and those who submit fraudulent documents could be subject to a permanent bar
against entry into the U.S. Nevertheless, we wonder whether sometimes the Consulates are
too eager to conclude fraud because of insufficient resources and time thereby
jeopardizing a person's life, liberty and the opportunity to live and enjoy the American
dream!!